I am a midwife and I live in Israel, a country where women live in the shadow of terrorism and violence.
Terrorism in Israel is a daily reality. Caution is a way of life and worry is a chronic state of mind. Terrorist attacks might occur anywhere, at any time, to anyone. Most Israelis know someone who has been involved in a terror attack. Few Israelis feel safe; they lack a basic sense of security in their lives and are apprehensive about their own safety and the safety of their families and friends.
Recurrent terrorism in Israel causes feelings of uncertainty and vulnerability, weakens the economy and curtails freedom of privacy and mobility. All leisure activities, including shopping in malls and eating in restaurants, entail frequent security checks. When a terror attack occurs, an immeasurable number of people are caught up in traumatic ripple effects. Eyewitnesses, families, friends and peers are all victimized, as are doctors, nurses, social workers, teachers and psychologists who are subjected vicariously to the trauma. Virtually anyone who is exposed to the media may suffer secondary trauma.
Terrorist attacks are deliberate, human made, unexpected and cause significant damage. This constellation of elements elicits high levels of rage, annoyance, hopelessness and depression. Gidron combined the results of six studies done in and outside of Israel and found that the mean prevalence of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) after a terrorist attack is estimated at 28.2%.
Israeli women were found to be 5.54 times more likely than Israeli men to have symptom criteria for PTSD, trauma related symptoms and feelings of depression. These findings are consistent with other reports in which women have been found to display more symptoms of PTSD than men following involvement in a traumatic event.
Between September 2000, considered the beginning of the “Al-Aqsa Intifada”, and the end of December 2003, there were a total of 20,058 terrorist attacks in the West Bank, the Gaza Strip and on the Israeli home front. A total of 6049 civilians and soldiers were injured; 904 were killed. Among the injured, 2943 were women, 1956 of them of childbearing age, between the ages of sixteen and forty-five.
Methodology
In 2004 I carried out a research project involving Israeli women who had been the victims of terrorist attacks and subsequently gave birth. My aim was to portray the nature of the shared experiences of these women in order to learn how maternity experiences can either augment the process of healing following a traumatic event or exacerbate the wound inflicted by the trauma.
I used qualitative phenomenological research methods in order to focus on the personal descriptions and perceptions of the maternity experiences of women who survived terrorist attacks. The phenomenological approach was chosen because phenomenology is committed to descriptions of experiences, not explanations or analyses.
Data was collected via open-ended interviews with eight women who shared the stories of their experiences. Acquaintances with these women were made via midwives, doctors and clinical psychologists who cared for them before, during or after their births. A digital voice recorder was used to document the interviews which were subsequently transcribed verbatim.
The interviews took place in a location chosen by the interviewee; seven out of eight chose to meet with me in their homes. The women were encouraged to feel free to refuse discussing any topic that was too painful for them. The narratives created by these in-depth interviews revealed the diversity and richness of their insights and perceptions. Written diaries provided added validity to the verbal materials collected in the interviewing process. Reading and analysis of these materials revealed emergent themes.
The Participants
The eight interviewees were Jewish Israeli women between the ages of twenty-four and fifty-four. Their ages at the time of the incident ranged from sixteen to thirty-three. The time period that passed between the incident and the interview ranged from six months to thirty years. All of the women are married. Five of the women classified themselves as non-religious; two described their religious orientation as traditional, one as religious. The women reside in small towns or cities in northern and central Israel. None of the interviewees reside in outlying settlements or disputed regions.
The incidents in which they were involved included: two hostage situations which resulted in crossfire between Israeli army rescue units and terrorists, two bus bombings, two restaurant bombings, a bombing in a public market and one in a shopping mall. In all of the incidents there were numerous fatalities and injuries.
Three of the eight interviewees were seriously injured and required long term hospitalization and rehabilitation. Three sustained injuries that weren’t life-threatening, but suffered from numerous shrapnel wounds and required short-term hospitalization and treatment. One suffered minor hearing loss only; one wasn’t injured physically at all.
One interviewee lost her husband and six-year old son in the incident. Another lost her sixteen-year old sister; a third lost her mother-in-law. One woman was taken hostage in an incident in which twenty-two sixteen-year-old classmates of hers were killed.
The Losses
A woman who has experienced the extreme and sudden violence of terrorism suffers a sequence of significant losses that threaten the sanctity of her self. She loses her sense of safety and the feeling of normalcy regarding her life. The woman she was before vanishes and is replaced by a woman she barely knows. She is suddenly filled with fears and lives inside a body that is different from the one she knew before. She looks at herself and sees the same skin, but her body reacts differently to the world around her. She loses her innocence, her optimism and her sense of trust.
The event never seems to erase itself from her memory. Death plays games with her by hovering overhead and peeking behind every corner. Her relationships with her family and friends change because she has changed. She may not be able to put into words what has happened to her. She feels lonely as she navigates through the puzzling landscape of her changed self and tries to continue to function within her existing social framework.
S: Before the incident, my life was filled with colors; I was happy, contented. I had the pink of flowers, greens, the sun, the blue sea and all the colors of the setting sun. After the incident, it was as if I passed through a dark tunnel and heard the echoing voice of the angel of death. When I came out of the tunnel I had only shades of grey and black. I was left with sadness, fear, pain and trauma.
O: I have trouble swallowing, drinking, eating, and speaking. I feel like I’m choking. Now my speech is better, but for a while I couldn’t speak at all. I still stutter, but not as badly as before. I feel like screaming to the heavens. Why did this happen to me? No one hears my voice. No one understands me. No one hears my words. I want to be understood. I’m different from everybody else. It’s as if I’m polluted and they’re clean
.
S: Three years have passed and I can still smell the odor. I can still see the shoes on the feet scurrying by me, the shattered glass everywhere, the bus stopped awkwardly in the middle of the intersection. There was so much blood; it was like water, flowing like a river.
Intra-Gestational Trauma: Voices from the Womb
Three of the interviewees were pregnant at the time of the incident, one in her fifth month, one in her seventh month, and one in her ninth month. They experienced the unique and mystifying juxtaposition of life developing within the confines of their own bodies while death stared them in the eyes and threatened both them and their babies. These women, when examining their behaviors during the incident, discovered, in retrospect, that their reactions were governed by voices within their wombs which dictated their actions instinctually. Their immediate reactions were orchestrated purely by their bodies; only afterwards could they gain cognitive understanding of their behaviors.
M: It was pure egoism, survival. It was as if my genes and the whole process of evolution itself were speaking to me. I received instructions from my belly to get off the bus as quickly and as carefully as possible. I then broke out in a sprint and didn’t stop running until I felt safe. My only concern was the content of my womb. Maybe I would have behaved differently if I hadn’t been pregnant.
C: It seems natural that I lost consciousness. It was too much for me to handle; fainting was a kind of escape. It seemed best to just sit and not risk falling because of the baby. I reminded myself that I was pregnant, that I’m allowed to sit, and that I shouldn’t exert myself. When I was first brought to the hospital, my thoughts were focused on the baby. I needed to know that he was OK.
A fascinating observation made concerning these three women who were pregnant at the time of the incidents was that none of them developed PTSD. The question raised by this finding is whether or not pregnancy serves as an intrinsic defense mechanism against traumatic stress. From the research of Shelley Taylor we now know that high levels of oxytocin, endorphins and estrogen provide a physiological resource for stress management in women.
Women who are pregnant have high physiological levels of these hormones; they enjoy the benefits of supplementary amounts produced by the placenta and the fetus. These hormones are known to promote the female survival behaviors of nurturing and affiliation in times of stress. These hormones are significantly higher than in non-pregnant states and may provide a possible physiological explanation for this phenomenon.
M: I went to a therapist six years after the incident. It was hard for me to believe that I didn’t have any traumatic stress reactions to the bombing, so I decided to go find out where my trauma was hiding. After three or four meetings, I finally understood. You idiot, girl, you were pregnant. You were taking care of your baby. When I got out of the bus, I was taking care of the baby, and I succeeded even though people were on the floor, crawling in between my legs.
Maternity through the Prism of Otherness
Five of the eight women became pregnant after the incident; only one of the five did so intentionally. After the initial shock wears off, pregnancy is more often than not accompanied by feelings of optimism, hope and renewal. For the woman who has lost a sense of who she is, pregnancy may seem like the perfect opportunity to regain normalcy and get her life back on track. Together with anticipating the birth of her child, she catches a glimpse of the possibility for her own rebirth which lights up the horizon of her darkened life. The developing fetus represents all that is good and pure. She yearns to bathe in the light of that goodness, to have a good birth and become a good mother for her baby.
The reality of this circumstance is one of inner conflict. This woman who has been wounded both physically and emotionally may doubt her ability to successfully carry a pregnancy to term. Fearful thoughts fill her head and dark sensations fill her body; she feels that she has been tainted by her experiences and may be polluting her fetus. She becomes a container for both darkness and light.
O: On one hand the idea of being pregnant gave me hope for change and renewal. On the other hand, there were doubts and uncertainty about the future. I thought about killing myself, about killing the baby. Abortion was an option that was too traumatic for me. I cried day and night. I decided to keep the baby and slowly learned to live with the idea, one day at a time. I had my ups and downs. I had no strength, even for my self, let alone for a baby. There were days of total despondency. It was a nightmare. Then she would kick, and I would feel that she was with me, and that I was with her.
Z: I lost twenty kilo. I didn’t believe that my body could sustain life. Something inside me had dissolved. After the initial shock wore off and my belly started to show, I realized that I was going to become a woman again, a mother. I have a fetus growing in my uterus; everything is normal, and I am becoming feminine and round. I suddenly understood that if my body was strong enough to nurture a developing fetus, then my soul was strong enough to nurse itself back to health. I took control again and found myself a therapist.
As the pregnancy matures and the birth approaches, her fears mount. She understands that giving birth may remind her of the circumstances surrounding her wounding. She is afraid of being dominated, of losing control and of being physically injured and altered again. Coping with her anxiety and dealing with so much uncertainty is perhaps more than she can handle. She may request an elective C-section to avoid the uncertainty of labor. If she is denied that request or begins labor spontaneously, she often does so already exhausted from the anticipation and dread of pain and suffering.
Z: I was scared of going back to the hospital, of seeing blood, of being cut. My fears were totally out of control; most of them were unwarranted. Somehow the bombing attached itself to the birth and got stuck. In the ninth month the fears peaked. I was afraid of seeing green uniforms, of being at the mercy of others, of being dependent on their decisions and the touch of their hands. I was afraid of the blood, the operating room, the anesthesia and the needles. I was scared to death. I was convinced that a c-section would be easier for me, it would hurt less and that there would be less blood than in a regular birth. Everything would be sterile; I would go in and come out with a baby.
Labor is painful for most women; birthing women utilize different strategies in order to cope with the pain. The physical pain of labor often stimulates the memory of previous painful experiences and triggers emotional reactions that may seem unrelated to the birth itself. The woman who has been previously exposed to extreme and sudden violence may find herself reliving reminders of the experience during labor. This may be overwhelming for her both emotionally and physically. Her ability to cope is harshly challenged and the strategies she had banked on may not be adequate. If members of her social support network are ignorant of what she is experiencing, they will be ineffective in helping her through this ordeal. In addition, words or actions of caregivers may trigger memories of helplessness and aggravate the situation even more. She may experience extreme anxiety and desperation while she is trying to give birth.
C: I was pushing and pushing, and at a certain stage I said, “Enough, I don’t want to push anymore. Do a vacuum delivery.” I lost the willpower to push, and I am certain that it was a result of the bombing. I felt like I couldn’t go on, that I couldn’t do more than I did. I couldn’t handle the pain anymore. I felt sorry for myself; sorry for the fact that I was suffering. The suffering reminded me of the way I felt after the incident. It doesn’t go away, the feeling that I am a terror victim, poor me. I felt it during the birth; it seems like an extension of the bombing, like one long experience of misery and suffering.
O: It’s not that I didn’t want the baby. I wanted her. I had gotten used to the idea. She was a fact. When I gave birth they handed her to me. When I saw her covered with blood, it reminded me of the bombing and it all came back to me. She looked like a piece of meat. I was shocked by the sight of her, really shocked. I couldn’t handle it. I pushed her away and told them to take her away.
C: I don’t think they even knew that I had been in a bombing incident. I didn’t tell them; I didn’t think that it was relevant at the time. Today I realize how important it is that they should know things like that. I had special fears and special needs. They really should have known.
Birth can act as a springboard for healing and transformation if the special sensitivities and needs of the wounded woman are expressed, honored and anticipated by those taking care of her. Birth may turn out to be a very significant and empowering experience for her. Much depends on the attitude, words and actions of the caregivers during this very sensitive and critical time.
Z: I said goodbye to my husband and my sister, I told them I’d be back soon and I went into the operating room. I sat on the bed by myself, I lay down by myself. My arms weren’t tied, no one told me to be quiet, not to move, to be a good girl and to stop yelling. There was no uncertainty. There were smiles in the air, there was music, and my family was waiting outside for me. The anesthesiologist stroked my cheek. I was in control and nothing hurt. I didn’t see a drop of blood. All of a sudden, the baby came out. She was perfect, healthy and simply amazing. I was elated and I wanted to tell them so, on the spot. “Do you know that you all are replacing my past, dreadful experiences with a new positive and optimistic experience? You’re talking with me, you’re being kind to me, and you’re laughing. I want to thank you all for this.”
The baby is born, with or without the intervention of midwives and doctors in attendance. Immense relief is the dominant emotion that follows the birth. The baby is surrounded by an aura of goodness which shines onto the mother. Breastfeeding helps create an intimate bond between baby and mother. The mother feels needed, connected and grounded. She has succeeded in becoming a mother; she holds her own baby, the fruit of her womb, in her arms. When she looks down on him, he reminds her of the potential for goodness, optimism and hope.
All of the pregnancies of the interviewees came to their completion at full term with infants of average weight and size. One baby was born by cesarean section, one by vacuum extraction and six by normal vaginal deliveries.
Z: The pregnancy was full of fears and anxieties. After the baby was born, the next morning, I felt that the fear was gone. I released the fear; I let it go, it was over. From the moment the baby was born I forgot about the bombing. My body will always remember giving birth. I felt a sense of relief, not physically, but in my heart, in my soul. I succeeded; I passed the test. She gives me hope, a reason to live. I want to be with her all the time. Maybe she’ll help me out of this nightmare. I’m nursing her and my appetite is back. I enjoy food again and I have someone to eat for. When I pull out my breast, she’s attached to me and I feed her, I know that she needs me. That means that I am needed, that I am useful. I am no longer broken; I have been repaired. She expanded my heart, my empathy, my softness and my motherhood.
As time goes on, she notices that her mothering is different. She is filled with fears concerning her baby’s well-being. She may limit his mobility in her attempt to avoid exposing him to potentially dangerous or threatening circumstances. Her mothering becomes over-protective and anxious. She fears that she will cause him physical harm by not being careful enough and emotional harm by being too careful and limiting his opportunities for exploration and growth. New inner conflicts develop. She has embodied the experience of the trauma, and in her mothering, she now passes it on to her child.
Z: I am hysterical when it comes to his safety. I can’t handle it when he’s sick. When he gets sick, I’m sick. I actually get depressed. I get angry if he falls and hurts himself at nursery school. I ask the teacher over and over again to watch him. I can’t stand the sight of blood or the smell of meat. It turns out that during the bombing pieces of flesh fell on me. It came up during a hypnosis session with my therapist. We’re all vegetarians now.
O: My girls don’t go to after-school activities anymore, no public swimming pool, nothing. I close them inside the house together with me. When my husband takes them out it makes me angry. I can’t stand to hear the baby cry. When I’m feeling bad I’m afraid to take care of her; I’m afraid of doing her harm just by being with her. Sometimes I imagine that I can create a bubble, and I can put her inside, and then she’ll be protected, and no harm can come to her. I can’t be inside there with her; I have my problems. She is pure good.
Transformational Processes
Loss can become a catalyst for change when transformation takes place. A woman who has been exposed to extreme and sudden violence and subsequently gives birth may experience the rebirth of her new self together with the birth of her new baby. Maternity may become the turning point of her life. In pregnancy she may discover the creative potential of her altered body; by giving birth she may recover the power that she lost when she was hurt. In mothering she develops a connection with her baby that may invigorate her life with new direction and purpose. The potential for growth and healing is enormous.
C: After the bombing I felt sorry for myself. But as a result of my pregnancy I learned to accept and appreciate my body. I’m a lot less critical of myself. Today I love my body more than ever. I didn’t use to think so, but today I think my body is beautiful.
E: Today I like my body more than ever. I think I’m both striking and beautiful. I like my uniqueness, my individuality. I feel that I’m different from everyone else in the world and that makes me feel good. It gives me strength. I believe in myself, in my own power. I believe that people will love me and my daughter, especially after what we’ve been through. I am a prize. Both my daughter and I are really special.
Z: I’m a different person. I learned that I’m strong and that I love life. Things that I used to see as tragedies make me laugh today, and the opposite. Things that were inconsequential have become high priority. I’ve matured since the bombing and the birth. I now understand that what really matters in life is my family, what I can give them and what I can receive from them. I had to be blown to pieces in order to understand these things.
Conclusions
Pregnancy, birth and mothering are the exclusive experiences of women and are among the most significant events in their lives. Past experiences play vital roles in shaping the course of these events and in determining their meaning. A woman’s perception of her maternity experiences will affect her mothering, her relationships, her children and her granchildren. Each woman carries along with her own history, the history of her mother’s pregnancies and births; likewise, her birth experiences will inevitably become a part of her children’s histories.
Those who find themselves intimately involved in the pregnancies, births and postpartum experiences of women touch their bodies and souls in many ways; we are witnesses to their pain and to their weaknesses. We are with them during moments of great apprehension and fear, and we share with them the exhilarating moment of birth. Our words and actions can be soothing and empowering; the memory of the care we provide may nurture a woman for the rest of her life.
For women who live in the shadow of trauma, routine prenatal exams, seemingly normal births and postpartum visits may suddenly and unpredictably turn into terrifying nightmares. We must constantly be sensitive to the possibility that our words and actions can trigger traumatic materials to surface; awareness of that possibility is the key to prevention.
Pregnancy, birth and mothering are opportunities for change, growth and transformation. We must keep in mind the knowledge that there is vast potential for both wounding and healing during this time. We are more often than not among the catalyzing factors for both of these very powerful processes. We cannot shy away from the enormous significance of our words and actions during this very vulnerable time.